Throwaway account. This happened many years ago after prom with my girlfriend. I hadn’t really thought about it for a long time, but I figured it would be a good story! Names have been changed.
At the very end of the year, a group of 10 us took the limo at the end of the night and stayed at our friend Katie’s house. She had been dating my buddy Brady for years. Brady and I were both good athletes, and Katie was the classic blonde cheerleader. My girlfriend (we will call her Paige) and I had been dating for a few months. Paige was one of the hottest girls in the whole school. Brunette, cute butt, and C cup tits. Also amazing lips that were the best to kiss. We had already had sex at this point, so this isn’t like a “lost my virginity at prom” story.
Katie’s parents were strict, but they let all of us stay there as long as we slept in an open area. We all just kind of had pillows and blankets around their big living room and slept on the floor or on the couches. We had drank before the dance, but we were all so tired and didn’t want to get busted by Katie’s mom for having booze. She kept on checking on us that evening. Instead of drinking, we all just watched a scary movie and talked/goofed around. We were all friends, even the people who weren’t couples.
After the movie the tv was turned off and pretty much everyone passed out. It was super uncomfortable on the floor, but Paige and I were teasing each other underneath the blanket we had.
At that age pretty much everyone is horny as fuck, and we had been grinding all night on the dance floor. Paige and I were also sneaky in general and had sex while watching a movie even with her family in the next room. At like 2 am, we were half awake spooning and I slowly went underneath her shirt to play with her tits. We were both wearing sweatpants, and she reached behind her and started to rub my dick. I started biting her ear and eventually I slid my hand down her pants and started playing with her pussy. She was soaking wet. We both wanted to have sex right there, but there was literally a bunch of people in the room, some sleeping on couches 5 feet away. It became too much and we needed to have sex, but we had to be super quiet. I opened the condom I had ready in my pocket and slid it on. I remember trying to open it super slowly so nobody heard the wrapper.
We were still under the covers, but I pulled down the back of her sweatpants and slid my dick inside her. She couldn't help it and let out a soft moan. We both paused and waited for like two minutes just to make sure nobody woke up from it. It was like pitch black and we couldn’t see much, but everyone still seemed asleep. I went in and out of her super slowly and kept biting her neck and nibbling her ear. We were probably doing this for like ten minutes, but we were going so slow to try and not wake anyone up. It was honestly so hard (lol no pun intended).
I lean up over Paige’s shoulder and looked to the other side of the room where Brady and Katie were sleeping. I could see the silhouette of Katie, her heading quickly bobbing up and down around Brady’s waist. Even though Paige and I were fucking painfully slow, I didn’t last more than a minute after seeing Katie sucking Brady off. I fell asleep inside Paige and had to hide the condom in my pocket when I woke up in the morning to throw it away in the bathroom. The next morning we all went to an amusement park for the day.
Sometime a couple weeks later, I remember Brady joking that Paige and I were fooling around in the room. His best friend who was sleeping on the couch saw us and told him. I just denied it lol.
Paige and I stayed together through college, and we are now married. We recently celebrated the first birthday of our third child.