![I Watched My Best Friend Get Everything I Wanted for 15 Years. Then the One Who Got Away Walked Into My Shop Wearing Leggings That Should Be Illegal [M30s] [F30s] [Mechanic] [Best Friend] [Voyeurism] [Making Out] [Old Flame] [Meet Cute] [Reunion] [No Sex] [Sacred Smut]](https://external-preview.redd.it/-P4_7aYP30qinnNNYMkiRriLk-oqd0Wo64fgh7Th5rs.png?width=1080&crop=smart&auto=webp&s=513730e003674f4ff7234425f133c510bb1dd3ca)
I Watched My Best Friend Get Everything I Wanted for 15 Years. Then the One Who Got Away Walked Into My Shop Wearing Leggings That Should Be Illegal [M30s] [F30s] [Mechanic] [Best Friend] [Voyeurism] [Making Out] [Old Flame] [Meet Cute] [Reunion] [No Sex] [Sacred Smut]
THE WRENCH
Inspired by Image #1
The wrench hits the concrete like a church bell nobody asked for.
"Yo. Little help?"
Nothing. Not even a flinch.
"Hey. Man. I'm elbow deep in your timing belt over here, can you grab that for me?"
Still nothing. I could set off a flare gun next to that girl's head and he wouldn't blink.
"Hey, motherfucker. Can you pick that up?"
Nothing. Not a laugh, not a middle finger, not even the reflexive kind of annoyance a guy usually throws his best friend for free. I've tested lesser versions of this theory. I once dropped a whole toolbox — on purpose, may God forgive me — just to see. He kissed her straight through it like the sound hadn't reached him yet, like it was still traveling.
So I let go of the belt tensioner, wipe my hand on my thigh, and pick the wrench up myself. Story of my life with these two. I've been getting my own wrenches since I was nineteen.
I look up before I mean to. Bad habit. Fifth time this car's been in my bay and fifth time they've ended up right here, her back against the door I need to get into, his hand doing something at the base of her spine like it's the only place his hand has ever wanted to be. She's got a fistful of his shirt like she's steadying herself against a wind nobody else can feel. His mouth is at her jaw, then her neck, then she tilts her head back against the window and her leg hooks behind his calf and his hand slides down past the waistband of her jeans, just the fingers, just enough, and her mouth opens in a way that has nothing to do with talking.
Annoying as hell. I mean that. Genuinely, deeply annoying, the way weather is annoying, the way it doesn't care what you had planned.
And also — I hate this about myself — kind of the best thing I get to watch on a Tuesday. The way her hips press forward into his hand. The way his forearm flexes when he finds whatever he's looking for. The small sound she makes that she thinks nobody hears, except I'm eight feet away under a hood that's been open this whole time.
I hear it. I always hear it. I go back to the timing belt.
I've had a front-row seat since we were kids, nineteen by the time the church sent us out on a youth group trip as chaperones — four of us, two guys, two girls, supposed to be the responsible ones. Supposed to be setting the example for a van full of high schoolers who already knew more than we wanted them to. The second girl chaperone got sick the first night and had to drive home, so it was just her, alone in the girls' room, and I don't have to tell you what an unlocked adjoining door means to two people who've been waiting for one.
I was the only one who actually wanted to be on that trip. I'd been looking forward to it for months — the campfire stuff, the worship sets, the late-night conversations where a kid finally opens up about something real. That was my thing. They just needed a weekend away from their parents and a door nobody was watching.
I heard it before Pastor Feldman did. The headboard first — rhythmic, insistent, finding the wall like it had somewhere important to be. Then her. Muffled at first, then less muffled, his name coming through the drywall in a voice I'd never heard her use before, climbing, breaking, the kind of sound that rewrites what you thought you knew about a person.
I lay there longer than I should have. I'm not proud of that. I'm also not going to pretend I'm different from every other nineteen-year-old boy who's ever heard something like that through a wall and felt his whole body respond to it before his conscience had a chance to weigh in. I listened. I listened to the pace change, to the bed frame shift its weight, to the moment everything went quiet and then came back louder and less careful. I listened to her finish — or what I thought was her finishing, a sound so raw and unguarded it felt like something I'd stolen just by being in the next room.
My hand was on my stomach. I'll leave it there.
Then footsteps in the hall. Slow, deliberate. Feldman.
Whatever I was doing stopped. Whatever I was feeling turned into something useful. I was up and cranking my portable speaker before I'd even decided to. Feldman knocked on my door — wrong door, thank God, some floor plan nobody explained right to a youth pastor in his socks.
"Turn that off."
"Why? I heard you knock. Can't you hear this?" I hit the wall three times, hard, right next to me, like I was demonstrating the racket — see, this old thing, paper thin — when what I was actually doing was telling two idiots on the other side of that drywall to freeze. They knew. They'd always known what three knocks meant.
He confiscated the speaker. Sat me down the next morning and told me I wasn't setting the kind of example the church expected from its chaperones. Told me he couldn't have someone representing the youth ministry who didn't take the responsibility seriously. I never chaperoned another trip. The thing I'd actually wanted to do — the campfires, the worship, the kids — gone. Because two people couldn't keep their hands to themselves for one weekend.
I never told either of them how close it came to going a different way that night, and if they ever put it together, neither one ever mentioned it. Idiots.
Speaking of...
There was one night I don't love thinking about. A party, too many years back, too much of somebody's cheap whiskey, and I kissed her. Just once, just bad judgment wearing my face. Her mouth tasted like lime and tequila and the last shred of a boundary I'd been respecting since the day I met her. For half a second she kissed me back — or I imagined she did, or the whiskey told me she did — and then she pulled back gentle instead of horrified, said "hey" the way you'd say it to a little brother who tripped in front of everybody, and never once made me carry it in front of him. Never told him a version that made me the villain. Just let it be a thing that happened to a dumb drunk kid one time, and then never happened again. I've spent every year since making sure I deserved that mercy. That's most of what my loyalty is, if I'm honest. Gratitude wearing a wrench belt.
I don't want her. I want to be clear about that, mostly to myself. I want what they have. There's a difference the size of a whole life. I want a version of this — the not-hearing-the-wrench-drop kind of gone, the fifth-time-in-my-bay-this-year kind of shameless — with somebody who looks at me like the world got quiet for her too.
They peel off my hood eventually, laughing about something only the two of them will ever be told, and wander off toward wherever people go when they've forgotten a car exists. I go back under the hood. Timing belt's not going to replace itself, and neither is whatever it is I keep waiting on.
I'm on my back under a Camry when the bell over the shop door goes.
"Hello? Anybody here?"
That sing-song hello women do walking into a strange place — bright, careful, pitched to carry just far enough and no farther.
I don't roll out yet. I tilt my head against the creeper and look toward the bay door.
"Be right out..."
I slide out at a normal speed. That's the part I can never explain right when I tell this story later — nothing about it was actually slow. But somewhere between deciding to roll out and my head clearing the bumper, everything downshifts into a different kind of time, the kind where you notice things you shouldn't have room to notice in half a second.
Feet first. White sneakers, clean enough to mean she doesn't wear them for anything that involves dirt. Calves disappearing into black leggings that fit her like they were sewn on this morning.
I roll out a little further.
Hips. The leggings curving over her in a way that makes my hands forget they're holding a socket wrench. An oversized linen button-up hanging open over a sports bra, sleeves pushed to her elbows, the fabric shifting when she moves so I catch the narrowing of her waist, the line of her hip bone just above the waistband.
A little further.
Her chest. Fuck. My. Life. The sports bra is doing its best to keep everything contained, and it is losing. She's the kind of built where compression just creates a different kind of problem — everything pushed together and straining against the fabric, and I can tell from the floor that the moment those got set free it would be the end of my entire life.
She's got a purse tucked in the crook of one elbow and her keys bouncing in her open palm. Sunglasses pushed up into dark hair pulled into a messy bun held together by a pencil.
And then her face.
Triangle shaped. Big dark eyes scanning the shop, still staying close to the bay door, one hand near the frame, keeping her exit within reach. Smart.
I know that face.
I roll out the rest of the way and go completely still on the shop floor.
Holy shit.
Same curls under the bun, just longer. Same way of standing like she's not sure she's allowed to take up the space yet. Same big dark eyes that used to make me forget my own locker combination in the tenth grade. Fifteen years has done absolutely nothing to this woman except make her better. Time did her favors she didn't need, and I am lying on the ground covered in grease looking up at her like the ceiling just opened and God decided to be funny.
She squints down at me.
"Oh my god — Junior? Is that you?"
Nobody's called me Junior in fifteen years.
"Oh — yeah. Hi." I get up. Wipe my hands on the rag. Try to stand like a man who has his shit together and not like a kid who just got his stomach turned inside out by a woman in leggings. "It's just Danny now."
"Danny?" She squints at the sign over the bay door. "Like Danny and Son's Auto Body? That's you?"
"Yeah. That's me. At least it is now. I mean, I used to just be the and Son's part even though it was just me." I clear my throat. "Anyway — hi."
She's smiling at me. The same smile that used to ruin my whole week just by showing up in a hallway.
I had a crush on this girl so bad in high school it gave me a stomachache every time she walked past my locker. I never said a word about it. Not once. Not to her, not to my buddy, not to anyone. I just carried it around like a wrench I couldn't put down, and eventually I convinced myself I'd set it somewhere and forgotten where.
Turns out I didn't forget. I just buried it under fifteen years of timing belts and oil changes and watching my best friend love somebody the way I wanted to love somebody.
And now she's standing in my shop. In leggings and a pencil in her hair. Looking like fifteen years was just a warmup for whatever she is now.
"So what's going on with your car?"
She starts describing the noise with her hands, badly, the way people do when they don't know the word for what's broken. Her fingers curl around invisible shapes in the air — round sounds, sharp sounds, a clunking that she mimes with a little fist pump that makes me want to die.
"It's like a — you know when you — it's not a click, it's more of a —" She makes the shape again with both hands, like she's molding the noise out of clay, and I realize I am watching the way this woman talks with my whole chest.
"A grinding?" I offer.
"Yes! A grinding. But only when I turn left. Is that bad?"
"Could be a lot of things. Probably not fatal."
She keeps calling me Junior. I don't correct her. I don't want to.
She's still describing symptoms — something about a light on the dash, a smell she can't place — and I'm nodding along but I'm also checking her left hand. Ring finger. Clean. No tan line, no indent, no ghost of anything that used to be there. Just bare skin and short nails and the way she keeps tucking a curl behind her ear that won't stay.
I file that away and hate myself a little for how fast I filed it.
"And then last week it made this sound like —" She puffs her cheeks out and makes a noise with her mouth that sounds nothing like any car problem I've ever heard and everything like the funniest thing a woman has ever done in my shop.
I laugh. I can't help it. A real one, surprised out of me, and she grins and shoves my arm — "Don't laugh at me, Junior, I'm serious!" — and the shove makes her bounce, just once, and I watch the sports bra lose an argument it did not know it was having.
I look away. I look back. She's still talking. She didn't notice.
I noticed.
I noticed the way her eyes get wider when she thinks I'm going to make fun of her and narrower when she's about to make fun of me. I noticed that she bites the inside of her cheek when she's thinking and that her keys are still in her hand but she stopped bouncing them the moment she saw my face. I noticed that she stands with one foot pointed toward the door even now, like she's always ready to leave, like nobody ever gave her a reason to plant both feet and stay.
I want to be that reason.
That thought arrives fully formed and without permission, and I let it sit there because there's nowhere else to put it and no point pretending it isn't true.
"Let's take a look," I say, and reach for the door.
My hand finds the small of her back before I've decided to put it there. Pure reflex — not even mine. I've been watching my buddy do this for fifteen years, one hand guiding her through every doorway like it was the most natural thing in the world. I never understood why he did it until right now, with my palm against the warm linen of her shirt and the curve of her spine underneath it. The answer is: because once your hand finds that spot on a woman you care about, moving it feels like a much bigger decision than putting it there.
Then my brain catches up to my hand.
We've been reacquainted for four minutes. I just touched her like we're leaving a restaurant after our tenth anniversary dinner, and I'm standing in a shop that smells like brake fluid with grease under my nails, and she is going to think I've lost my mind.
I start to pull my hand away.
"Ooh." She looks back at me over her shoulder. "What a gentleman." A smile, the kind that makes me forget I was panicking. "Thanks, handsome."
She says it like a joke, except she's still looking at me when the joke should be over.
My brain stops working entirely.
"Sure," I say. "Yeah. Let's go see what we got."
I'm already married to this woman in my head and we've barely said hello, and I'm walking her to her car with my hand on her back, and she just called me handsome, and I said let's go see what we got like a man who has never in his life been smooth about anything.
The bell swings behind us.
I hold the door.