First "Real" Date (And Why Restaurant Tables Are Evil) [F18/F18] [Dominance / Submission] [Oral] [Voyeurism]
The text from Riley sits on Sarah’s phone like a lit match in dry grass, just waiting for a breeze to turn everything to ash. I stare at it until the words blur— Hey. Been a while. Saw you on campus the other day—looked good. Coffee sometime? Catch up?—and the screen dims, then goes black, mercifully hiding the evidence. But it's too late. The words are burned into my brain, looping like a bad TikTok algorithm.
Sarah sets the phone face-down on the nightstand—careful, deliberate, like she's handling a live grenade instead of a slab of glass and circuits. Her fingers linger on it for a second too long, and I catch the way her jaw tightens, just a flicker, before she turns back to me with that soft, reassuring smile she pulls out when she knows I'm spiraling.
“It’s nothing,” she says quietly, her voice all calm waters on the surface while I feel like I'm drowning underneath. “Just an old friend. I haven’t talked to her in years.”
I nod. Swallow the lump in my throat that's part lump, part scream. Nod again, like if I keep bobbing my head it'll make the lie true.
“Okay.”
But it's not okay. My stomach is doing that slow, nauseating twist I remember from middle school, back when I'd see Katie—my first real crush, the one with the freckles and the laugh that made my knees wobble—holding hands with some dumb boy in the hallway, his thumb stroking her knuckles like he had any right. Except this feels worse, sharper, like someone's twisting a knife in my gut instead of just punching it. Because Sarah is mine now. Mine in the way that makes my chest ache every time she looks at me like I’m the only thing in the room, the only thing that matters. And now Riley's name is glowing in my head like a neon sign saying "Remember? She's not just yours. She was someone else's first."
She reaches for me, fingers brushing my cheek, cool against my flushed skin. “Ellie. Talk to me.”
I force a smile that feels like cracked glass, sharp edges digging into my lips. “I’m fine. Really. Just… tired. From earlier. All the coming. And the crying. And the coming again.” I try to make it sound light, like one of my usual self-deprecating jokes, but it falls flat, lands with a thud in the space between us.
She doesn’t laugh. She just watches me, eyes searching mine like she's trying to read the fine print on my soul. “We don’t have to pretend it’s nothing if it’s something.”
I shake my head, too fast, hair whipping across my face. “It’s not. I trust you.”
And I do. Mostly. God, I want to trust her completely, the way I trust gravity or the way coffee burns my tongue every morning no matter how careful I am. But there's this tiny seed planted now, burrowing into the soft soil of my insecurities, sprouting roots that whisper "What if?" What if Riley's better? What if Sarah misses whatever they had? What if I'm just the rebound from her "sort of" dating phase, the safe choice after the excitement?
We spend the rest of the afternoon in a weird, fragile bubble—showering together under the too-hot spray of her dorm bathroom, her hands slow and soapy on my back, tracing suds down my spine while I lean into her, eyes closed, pretending the water can wash away the knot in my chest. Gentle kisses under the stream, no urgency, just her lips on my shoulder, my neck, tasting like clean and salt and a little bit of desperation. We order Thai takeout—pad see ew for me, extra spicy because I need something to burn away the sour taste in my mouth—and eat it cross-legged on her bed, sheets still rumpled from earlier, the faint musk of sex lingering in the air like a ghost. We scroll through dumb TikToks on her phone, the one she powered back on but keeps face-down now, like out of sight means out of mind. Every time she laughs at some cat video or a thirst trap edit, the sound bubbles up genuine and warm, and I feel a little less like the floor is going to drop out from under me. Her head on my shoulder, her fingers absentmindedly tracing patterns on my knee—circles, hearts, something that might be her initials if I squint.
By evening, the text from Riley feels farther away, like a bad dream fading in the light. Not gone, but blurry around the edges.
Sarah glances at her closet, then at me, her eyes lighting up with that mischievous spark that always makes my pulse skip. “Hey. What if we did something… normal tonight?”
“Normal?” I echo, eyebrow quirking up. Normal for us lately has been stolen moments in the stacks, frantic hookups in her bed, my face buried between her thighs while the world outside keeps spinning oblivious.
“Like. A date. A real one. Dinner. Movie. No hiding in my apartment or fingering each other under dining hall tables.”
I raise an eyebrow, trying to play it cool even as heat pools low in my belly at the memory. “You say that like it’s a bad thing.”
She grins—crooked, soft, the kind that makes my heart flip-flop like a fish on dry land. “It’s not. But I want to take you out. Properly. Like girlfriends do.”
Girlfriends. The word hits me square in the chest, a warm bloom spreading out, chasing away some of the chill from Riley's shadow. Girlfriends. Me and Sarah. Out in the world, holding hands, stealing glances, like every rom-com I've ever binge-watched while pretending I wasn't imagining a girl in the lead role.
I feel my face heat, cheeks probably glowing like stoplights. “Okay. Yeah. Let’s do that.”
She kisses me quick—bright, happy, her lips tasting like the last bite of spicy noodles—then starts digging through her drawers for something clean, muttering about how all her good shirts are in the laundry.
I go back to my dorm for the first time in days, the walk across campus feeling exposed, like everyone can see the hickeys peeking over my collar or the way my thighs still ache faintly from earlier. My roommate's out—thank god—and the room smells like stale coffee from her Keurig and my unwashed laundry pile that's starting to resemble a small mountain. I stand in front of the tiny mirror taped to the closet door and stare at myself, really look.
Hair a mess, tangled from Sarah's fingers. Hickeys blooming like purple constellations across my neck and collarbone, each one a map of her mouth, her teeth, her claim. Lips still swollen, red from kisses and bites. Eyes bright in a way I don’t recognize—alive, scared, but alive. I look… happy. Terrified. But happy. Like I've finally cracked open that shell I've been hiding in since Dad died, since Mom started looking at me and Aria like we were her lifelines, fragile and precious and not to be risked on something as messy as feelings.
A flashback hits me—Dad's funeral, the smell of lilies choking the air, Mom clutching that rosary so hard her knuckles went white, whispering prayers while Aria held my hand tight enough to bruise. "Be good girls," she'd say later, over frozen dinners and forced smiles. "Make him proud." And I tried. Straight A's, no parties, no boys (ha, joke's on her), just quiet Ellie burying herself in books and bad poetry. Until Sarah. Until the pining turned into touching, and now here I am, picking out a dress for our first real date while my sister's "Finally" text still glows in my phone like approval.
I pick the black dress I bought last semester on impulse—the one with thin straps and a hem that hits mid-thigh, clinging just enough to make me feel exposed but sexy. It’s too fancy for campus, but tonight I don’t care. I pair it with the only nice boots I own—scuffed but black, heeled enough to make my legs look longer—swipe on mascara that clumps a little because my hands are shaking, dab concealer over the worst of the marks (it mostly works, turning them from screams to whispers), and spritz the perfume Sarah says makes me smell like “summer sex and vanilla.” The scent fills the room, sweet and heady, making me think of her nose buried in my neck, inhaling deep while her hands wander.
When I text her I’m ready, she replies instantly:
— On my way. Wear the red lipstick. The one that makes me want to ruin it.
My thighs clench, a pulse of heat shooting straight to my core. Fuck. I dig it out from my makeup bag—the bold red one I bought on a dare from Aria last year—and swipe it on, careful not to smudge. It makes my lips look fuller, kissable, ruinable.
She picks me up outside my dorm in her beat-up hatchback—windows down, Mitski playing soft through the speakers, that melancholy voice wrapping around us like smoke. She’s wearing dark jeans that hug her thighs, a fitted white button-down with the sleeves rolled up to her elbows, showing off the faint tan lines from summer, hair loose and wavy, falling over one shoulder. She looks like trouble wrapped in Sunday best, the kind of girl who'd steal your heart and your sanity in one go.
She whistles low when she sees me, eyes raking down my body slow enough to make me shiver. “Fuck. You trying to kill me?”
I laugh, slide into the passenger seat, the leather cool against my bare thighs. “Maybe.”
She leans over the console, kisses me slow—tongue just teasing the seam of my lips, tasting like mint gum and anticipation—then pulls back before I can deepen it, leaving me chasing her mouth.
“Later,” she promises, voice low and gravelly. “Date first. Ruin you after.”
The words send a thrill down my spine, settling hot between my legs. I buckle in, try to ignore the way my panties are already damp just from that kiss.
The restaurant is small, Italian, tucked between a laundromat humming with dryers and a record store blasting faint indie rock through the walls. Candlelight flickers from tables, checkered tablecloths rumpled like they've seen better days, the air thick with garlic, red wine, fresh bread, and that undercurrent of possibility, like anything could happen in a place this cozy and dim.
We get a corner booth, tucked away from the main floor, the vinyl seat sticking slightly to my thighs as I slide in. Sarah sits across from me, her knee brushing mine under the table, sending a spark up my leg.
She orders wine for both of us—cabernet, deep red, like blood (fake IDs still work miracles, thank God for Aria's hookup last year). I order pasta carbonara, creamy and indulgent. She orders risotto with mushrooms, something earthy and rich. We talk about stupid things—midterms looming like storm clouds, the professor in our lit class who always smells like wet dog and old books, whether Mitski is overrated or underrated (underrated, obviously, her lyrics hit too close to home for me right now).
It's easy. Normal. Like we're just two girls on a date, not two best friends who've exploded into something more, something terrifying and beautiful. But under the table, her foot finds mine—boot nudging my ankle, playful at first.
I shoot her a look, half-warning, half-invitation.
She smiles innocently, sipping her wine, but her eyes are dark, promising.
Her boot slides up my calf—slow, deliberate, the leather smooth and cool against my skin, tracing the muscle there.
I shift in my seat, crossing my legs, but that only traps her foot higher, against my knee.
She keeps talking about some podcast she listened to on queer history, voice steady as ever, while her toes trace the inside of my knee, then higher, inching up my thigh.
Heat builds slow, a simmer in my core. I clench my fork tighter, try to focus on twirling pasta, but every nudge sends a jolt straight to my clit.
By the time the food arrives—steaming plates set down with a clink—the air feels thicker, my breaths shallower.
She drags her foot along my inner thigh—higher, higher—until the tip of her boot nudges the damp cotton between my legs, right over my seam.
I choke on a sip of wine, coughing into my napkin while fire licks up my spine.
“You okay?” she asks, all wide-eyed concern, while pressing just enough to make my clit throb, a firm rub through the fabric.
“Fine,” I squeak, voice pitching up like a cartoon character.
The waiter—older guy with a mustache—asks if we need anything else, pepper or parmesan.
Sarah smiles sweetly, foot still circling slow. “We’re good. Thanks.”
He leaves, oblivious.
Her foot presses harder—firm, insistent circles through the thin barrier of my panties, the pressure building like a wave.
I grip the edge of the table, knuckles white, biting my lip to stifle a whimper.
“Sarah—” I hiss, half-plea, half-warning.
“Shh. Eat your pasta.” Her voice is casual, but her eyes are locked on mine, hungry, watching every twitch of my face.
I try. I really do. Lift a forkful to my mouth, chew mechanically, but every time I swallow she rocks her heel against me—slow grind, perfect pressure—and sparks dance behind my eyes. My thighs tremble, trying to close around her foot, but she wedges it firmer, unrelenting.
She’s watching me like I’m dessert, like the risotto in front of her is just a prop.
I’m dripping. I can feel it—soaking through my panties, probably staining the booth seat, the slick heat spreading with every press.
She leans forward across the table, voice velvet-low, barely audible over the murmur of other diners and clinking glasses. “You’re so wet I can smell it from here. That sweet, musky scent—it's driving me crazy.”
I whimper—quiet, desperate, my free hand fisting the tablecloth.
People are around us—couples laughing, a family in the corner—but the booth hides us, the tablecloth a merciful curtain.
“Bathroom,” I whisper, voice wrecked. “Now. Please.”
She grins, sharp and triumphant. “After dessert.”
We suffer through tiramisu—creamy, coffee-soaked, dusted with cocoa that sticks to my lips. Her foot never stops, circling, pressing, edging me closer and closer until I'm shaking, thighs quivering, breaths coming in short pants. I can barely taste the dessert, my world narrowed to the ache between my legs, the need coiling tight.
When the check comes she pays fast—card slapped down, generous tip scribbled—then grabs my hand under the table, pulls me up on wobbly legs toward the back.
The single-stall bathroom is tiny—dim light from a flickering bulb, chipped tile floor cool under my boots, mirror fogged from someone's earlier hot shower, the air thick with lemon cleaner and a faint undercurrent of bleach. The door clicks locked behind us.
She spins me around, pins me against the sink—cold porcelain digging into my lower back.
Her mouth crashes into mine—hungry, bruising, teeth nipping my bottom lip, tongue sweeping in to taste wine and desperation. Hands slide under my dress, rough and urgent, yanking my panties down my thighs in one swift pull. The fabric clings wetly before pooling at my ankles.
I step out of them—leave them on the floor like evidence, forgotten.
She drops to her knees on the tile, no hesitation, pushes my dress up around my waist.
Her tongue finds my clit—flat, broad licks that make my knees buckle, fire exploding outward.
I grab the sink behind me, knuckles white on the edge, head falling back against the mirror with a thud.
She sucks—gentle at first, then hard, pulling whimpers from my throat—while two fingers tease my entrance, circling the slick heat before sliding inside, easy and deep, curling up to hit that spot that makes stars burst.
“Fuck, Sarah—” I gasp, hips bucking forward.
She hums against me, vibration buzzing straight to my core, adding a third finger. The stretch is perfect, aching, full, my walls clenching around her.
I’m loud—too loud, moans echoing off the walls—but the music from the restaurant filters through the door, bass thumping cover.
She thrusts steady, tongue flicking my clit in rhythm, sucking until I'm trembling, legs shaking.
I come fast—shattering, hips grinding against her face, wetness gushing over her fingers, her chin, a sob ripping from my chest.
She doesn’t stop. Keeps licking, thrusting slow now, drawing out the aftershocks until I’m twitching, oversensitive, begging “Please—too much—Sarah—”
Only then does she pull back, lips shiny, eyes dark and satisfied. Stands, kisses me deep—lets me taste myself, salty-musky-sweet on her tongue.
“Your turn,” she whispers, voice rough.
We switch—me pushing her against the wall, her dress hiked up, panties shoved aside with trembling fingers.
She’s soaked—lips swollen, pink and glistening, clit hard and begging under my tongue.
I lick slow—learning her all over again, savoring the taste, the heat—then faster, flicking, sucking while three fingers slide inside her, deep and curling.
She threads her fingers through my hair—pulls hard, guiding me, hips rocking.
“Like that—fuck, Ellie, right there—”
She comes with a broken moan—thighs clamping around my head, wetness flooding my mouth, her walls pulsing around my fingers.
We kiss again—messy, desperate—tasting each other, tasting the faint soap from the sink, tasting the risk of getting caught, the thrill buzzing under our skin.
When we finally pull apart we’re wrecked—hair mussed, lipstick smeared across chins and collars, dresses askew, breaths ragged.
She laughs—breathless, head thrown back. “Best first date ever.”
I grin, wiping my mouth with the back of my hand. “We’re disgusting.”
“The best kind.”
We clean up as best we can—paper towels rough against sensitive skin, cold water splashed on faces, quick kisses stolen in the mirror's reflection.
Back in the car she drives with one hand on the wheel, the other on my thigh—fingers tracing lazy patterns higher and higher, dipping under my hem.
We don’t talk about Riley. Not yet. The wine buzzes warm in my veins, the afterglow chasing away the shadows for now.
But then she turns off the main road, pulls into a motel parking lot—the cheap one off campus with the flickering neon sign that buzzes "Vacancy" in buzzing pink, gravel crunching under tires.
I blink. “What—?”
She grins, kills the engine. “Booked it earlier. Surprise. Figured we could use a change of scenery. No nosy roommates, no thin walls.”
My heart stutters—excitement mixed with that familiar panic. A motel. Like we're adults, like this is real.
Inside, the room smells like bleach and cheap air freshener—fake pine that clashes with the faint musty undertone. Queen bed with a scratchy comforter, one lamp casting yellow light, and—oh god—a mirror on the ceiling, reflecting us back like a porno set. Classy as fuck.
We don’t waste time. Clothes hit the floor—dress pooled at my feet, her shirt unbuttoned slow, revealing lace bra that makes my mouth water.
She pushes me onto the bed—gentle but firm, mattress dipping under my weight.
Straddles my hips, knees bracketing me, heat of her core pressing against my stomach.
“Touch yourself,” she says, voice commanding but soft, eyes locked on mine. “I want to watch.”
Heat floods my face—and lower. I slide my hand between my legs, fingers finding my clit, circling slow, slick from earlier.
She mirrors me—fingers on her own clit, slow strokes, hips rolling slightly.
We watch each other—breathing syncing, moans soft at first, then louder, the room filling with wet sounds, gasps.
She leans down—kisses me while our hands work between us, tongues tangling.
Then she shifts—turns around, settling her thighs over my face, her face between mine.
- It’s clumsy at first—elbows digging, knees slipping, both of us laughing into each other’s thighs, the vibration adding to the tease.
Then it clicks. Perfect alignment.
Her mouth on me—tongue circling my clit, sucking gentle, fingers sliding back inside, thrusting slow.
My mouth on her—long licks through her folds, tasting her arousal fresh and tangy, flicking her clit while fingers pump deep.
We move together—hips rocking, moans muffled against wet skin, the mirror above showing it all: her back arched, my hands gripping her ass.
I come first—shuddering, crying out against her, walls clenching, gushing over her tongue.
She follows seconds later—thighs shaking, wetness flooding my mouth, a sob of my name.
We collapse—sweaty, trembling, laughing breathless into the pillows.
She crawls up, pulls me close, kisses my forehead soft.
“I love you,” she whispers, voice cracking a little.
“I love you too.” The words come easy now, but they hit hard, blooming warm in my chest.
We lie there—tangled, hearts slowing, skin cooling. But the afterglow demands more; we're not done.
Sarah rolls over, digs in her bag—pulls out a small velvet pouch. “Brought something. If you're up for it.”
My curiosity piques, mixed with nerves. She pulls out a small vibrator—sleek, black, bullet-shaped—and a bottle of lube.
“Toys?” I breathe, excitement twisting with that familiar gay panic. We've done fingers, mouths, but this... escalation.
She nods, eyes searching mine. “Only if you want. We can stop anytime.”
Consent check-in—always, even in the heat. It makes me love her more, crave her dominance wrapped in care.
“Yeah. Show me.”
She clicks it on—low buzz filling the room, vibration humming through the air.
Starts on herself first—pressing it to her clit, gasping, hips bucking. “Like this. Feels... intense.”
Then hands it to me. I mimic, the buzz against my oversensitive clit making me jolt, pleasure sharp and electric.
She watches, then takes over—holding it steady while her fingers slide inside me again, thrusting in time with the pulses.
“Fuck—Sarah—it's too—oh god—” I babble, building fast.
“Come for me,” she murmurs, free hand pinching my nipple lightly, adding kink's edge.
I shatter—harder than before, squirting a little, wetness soaking the sheets, tears pricking my eyes from the intensity.
She switches—me using it on her, fingers deep, until she comes with a cry, body arching.
But we're escalating. She pulls out more from the bag—a strap-on, harness simple, dildo curved and ridged.
My breath catches. “You... planned this?”
“Wanted to surprise you. Top you properly.” Her voice is husky, but she pauses. “If it's too much—”
“No. Want it. Want you.” Craving her dominance, the fullness.
She straps it on—adjusting, lubing generously. I watch, mesmerized, arousal rebuilding.
She positions me on my back, legs spread, pillow under my hips.
“Ready?” Kiss to my inner thigh.
“Yes. Please.”
She slides in slow—inch by inch, the stretch burning sweet, filling me completely.
I gasp, nails digging into her shoulders.
She stills, lets me adjust. “Okay?”
“Move. Fuck me.”
She does—slow thrusts at first, building rhythm, the base grinding against her clit.
Sensations overwhelm: pressure deep, ridges dragging, her breasts brushing mine, sweat-slick skin sliding.
Dirty talk spills: “You feel so good around me—tight, wet—mine.”
“Yes—yours—harder—”
She picks up pace, one hand on my clit, rubbing circles.
I come—sobbing, clenching around the toy, tears streaming, laughter bubbling through because it's emotional, raw, love exploding.
She follows, grinding hard, moaning my name.
We collapse, her pulling out gentle, harness discarded.
Cuddling close, breaths syncing.
My phone buzzes on the nightstand—ignored.
Hers buzzes next.
She reaches for it—lazy, sated.
Reads the screen.
Her body goes stiff. I feel it ripple through her, tension coiling.
“Sarah?”
She turns the phone, face pale.
New text from Riley:
— Saw you leave the Italian place with someone. Cute dress. Still up for coffee tomorrow? Miss talking to you.
Attached: a blurry photo—from across the street, us hand-in-hand, laughing.
My heart stops. The room spins.
Stalked? Watched?
Sarah looks at me—guilty, panicked, pleading.
“Ellie—I swear, I didn't—”
The door knocks—sharp, insistent.
We freeze.
Mom's voice through the wood: “Ellie? Sarah? I know you're in there. Open up.”
My blood runs cold.
She's here. Early.
And Riley's watching.
Fuck.
---