My Worst Nightmare part 1
I've never posted this story anywhere else but I've thought about it many times. I'm going to post part one and if there's any interest in the second part please comment and I'll add it.
Names have been changed for privacy as this story is real and not a work of fiction.
It started off as a somewhat awkward Saturday afternoon where I was with my girlfriend Alicia (now wife) and her female cousin. My wife was 23 at the time and her cousin Brooke was 22. I was almost 25 years old. Now, to be honest my wife's cousin didn't like me and I wasn't a fan of her. I don't think there was a specific reason why we didn't like each other, but our personalities were very different. She was loud, obnoxious and the kind of woman who just has a problem with everyone. I think a lot of her resentment for me came from the fact that Alicia no longer spent all her time with Brooke since I came around. Alicia and I met through university and we were together almost two years now. Brooke also had a boyfriend named Liam who was my age.
Now that I've set the scene let me describe Brooke a bit more. Brooke is about 5'4" and thin. She has small perky boobs and a full ass. I'd be lying if I said I didn't think she was incredibly hot. She was actually much more attractive than Alicia, who is about the same height but a bit heavy. Now I love my wife, I am also a bigger guy and would never judge my wife's body but I couldn't help but imagine Brooke naked. Her perky boobs and petite figure just screamed feminity. She flaunted her pierced nipples through her tops and often wore leggings that were somewhat see through.
On this day she was in a bad mood. She wanted to tan on her back deck but Liam wasn't home to keep an eye out for visitors and I was there. There was no way she'd wear a bikini or possibly even less with me present. She made it clear that she wished I wasn't there but Alicia didn't seem to care, she was used to Brooke's attitude.
Now although I'd never seen Brooke undressed she couldn't see the same for me. When Alicia and I first met she admitted that she had shown Brooke a dick pic i'd sent her. The pic was me standing in front of a mirror, erect with my chubby 245lbs body and somewhat shameful 4.5 inch dick fully visible. Alicia apologized and felt bad but she said she showed Brooke because she had seen several nudes of Liam's when they first got together. Ever since then Brooke likes to make snarky comments at me, she sometimes calls me shrimp or likes to brag about Liam's "impressive man cock". Long story short, she enjoyed humiliating me.
I never expected that Brooke would see me nude in person, let alone kick me in the balls. But within the hour of this afternoon I would be embarrassed more than ever before. Alicia and I found ourselves nude in front of Liam and Brooke with Liam pinching Alicia's nipples and Brooke smacking and kicking my balls. I can admit I enjoyed it in some weird fantasy way, but ultimately I was very ashamed of myself that day. I haven't been in the same room as Brooke now in almost three years. But anytime I see a picture, or hear her name I shutter inside with embarrassment.
Comment for part 2 if interested