My first BF accidentally fingered my ass, now all I can think about is anal
Funny story but back when me and my first boyfriend were first starting to fool around, we were still at college and living with our families so intimate time together was hard to find. One evening though I was over at his place and while we were making out and getting handsy, I could feel his cock getting hard against me. I took things further than we had at that point and put my hands down his pants and starting touching and stroking his cock.
He reacted by putting his hand into my jeans too but he had no idea what to do or where to go. He fumbled his way into my underwear but instead of my pussy, he started putting his finger in my ass. By this point it was too late and I wasn't going to tell him to put that finger in pussy instead now because I didn't want to risk an infection so I just let him carry on. We were still fully clothed so he wasn't able to go very deep and hurt me and it actually felt surprisingly nice
We kept making out and playing like this until I made him cum in his pants and I went home. I never told him he'd been playing with my ass and next time we actually took our clothes off lol and pointed him to my pussy. I've never experimented with anything else anal with a guy since then but it's still on my mind a lot and at some point I'm definitely going to bring it up my with current bf. I just need to be brave!