Shh... I Won't Tell - Chapter One [F26][M27][Slow Burn][Jesse & Claire][Friends To Lovers][Love Triangle][Envy]
The first three chapters are not very spicy, they are build up. Fair warning.
Synopsis: Claire has been in love with her best friend, Jesse since the eighth grade. On the eve of Jesse's 27th birthday, Claire finally finds the courage to tell him how she feels, until she finds him with Vanessa, his new girlfriend he never mentioned having.
Jesse's always known he had feelings for Claire, but he never dared chase them, for fear of ruining the friendship they share. Thankfully, he hides it well, until he can't be bothered to fight it anymore.
And Vanessa? She's the catalyst that sets everything in motion.
This whole thing was inspired by Sombr's song "Back To Friends." Tropes include: friends to lovers, cheating, a love triangle, revenge, harbored feelings, miscommunication, and games of love. Pairings include F/M || F/F || F/F/M
There's about 26 chapters, give or take. I plan to post at most one per day. Hope you like it and as always thanks for reading!
Claire
The elevator buzz echoes in my ears and the doors slowly creak open. Reluctantly, I step inside with a card in my purse that will hopefully change the trajectory of my life for the better, forever.
Standing outside my best friend Jesse’s apartment, I somehow muster up the fleeting courage to lift my fist and knock on his door. It’s mere minutes before midnight, and I’m surprising him with a slice of his favorite chocolate cake from the little mom and pop bakery across town for his birthday. Well, that and a card in which I’ve written all the things and bountiful reasons why I can’t help but love him.
After standing there for a few minutes contemplating and debating what I’m going to say to him, I knock on the door. A minute passes and I consider knocking again until I hear the faint click of a lock. When the door swings open my smiling face falters. Jesse’s brows are knit, his lips are pink and swollen, and his messy dark brown hair falls haphazardly in his face.
“Surprise!” I pull him in for a hug, but when I pull back he’s grimacing. “What’s wrong?”
“Claire, now’s not a good time.” He says while gripping the back of his neck awkwardly. A sliver of his abdomen shows, catching my eye just as I hear a vivacious voice round the corner.
“Come back to bed, babe.” Coos a female tone and my spine instantly stiffens. My cheeks paint themselves a lovely shade of puce while I feel like I’m going to puke any minute now. He has a woman with him? Fuck! Dainty hands wrap themselves around his trim waist as a gorgeous brunette peeks out at me from behind his back. “Who’s this?” She asks him while pulling away and crossing her arms. I could say the same thing.
“No one.” I say to her. “Don’t worry, I’m not staying.” From my purse I extract the small carry out container with a slice of cake for Jesse while forcing the card deeper into my bag. “Happy birthday. Sorry for interrupting your er… evening.”
Pacing my way back down the hall, I head for the elevator all frazzled and flustered. Just as I’m pushing the button to close the doors an arm juts out, stopping them from shutting. I glance up as Jesse steps into the lift and embraces me. Immediately, I sink into him. “Thank you for the cake.” He says to me softly. “That was Vanessa you met back there.” He mentions, his voice coming out flat. “I’ve been seeing her for a few weeks now.” As if he needs to explain anything to me. We’ve been friends since middle school, always paired together because of our last names, Harrison and Hart. It brought us together in the most monumental way possible.
“You don’t owe me an explanation.” I tell him softly. “Go enjoy your birthday. I hope you like the cake.” My feeble voice barely rings out. “I’ll see you tomorrow?” I ask meekly.
“Dinner at Finnigan’s like always?”
“Always.” I say as he pulls me in for a quick hug that crushes my bones and squashes my spirit at the same time, knowing I’m not the one he’s returning to, instead I’m the one he’s letting go. He steps back and waves at me as the doors slowly close shut. Once I’m free from his guilty gaze I lean back against the wall and hold my head in my hands. That did not go like I had planned.
***
I continue to check the time on my phone, wondering if he’s ever going to bother to show, because lately Jesse’s been a little flaky. We were supposed to meet at seven and it’s going on seven-thirty. Where the hell is he? I’m about to click on his contact and call him when I hear my name coming from the entrance.
“Claire!” He calls as he makes his way over to me, his hand clasped to another’s. Behind him is the woman from last night, Vanessa. Standing up straight, I greet him with a hug as I wait for him to introduce the two of us. He glances at Vanessa and throws an arm around her possessively. “Claire, this is my girlfriend, Vanessa. Vanessa, this is my best friend, Claire.” Jesse gestures between the two of us. Vanessa smiles at me while I awkwardly wave in her direction.
Finding my voice, I say to her, “It’s nice to meet you.” I tuck a piece of my dirty blonde hair behind my ear, chuckling. “Sorry about last night. I didn’t think Jesse was going to have company. I didn’t know...”
Vanessa turns to him as we settle into the booth. “You haven’t told her about me? We’ve been together over a month!” She says ‘her’ with venom spitting from her tongue. I’m watching Jesse as he squirms in his seat while I also wonder why I’m only now just finding out about Vanessa.
He reaches for her hand and she lets him take it. “I wanted to make sure we were serious first.” My throat constricts as an uncomfortable chill prickles its way down my spine. They’re serious? How serious? Oh my god, does he love her? I can feel the sweat as it starts to form on my back and puddle in my palms.
“Oh, Jesse.” Vanessa leans over and kisses him with tongue, practically marking her territory right in front of me. “Isn’t he the sweetest?” She asks me while batting her long eyelashes in his direction, her claw like nails digging into his chest. I get it bitch, he’s yours.
“Oh, he’s the bee's knees.” I reply facetiously while scrunching up my nose and reaching for my drink. This is going to be a long, torturous evening.
Once the waiter comes and takes our orders, I start the dreaded conversation. “So how did you two meet?” I ask as I start sucking down my second martini.
Vanessa blushes with a sultry little smile on her lips. “I work at Giselle’s. I’m a waitress there.” Giselle’s is a Gentleman’s club one town over. I glance from her smile down to her chest and the math makes sense. As much as I refuse to admit it out loud, she’s gorgeous. With piercing blue eyes, a few shades lighter than mine, full pink lips, and eyelashes that never end, she’s everything I wish I was while also being everything I hate. And I hate that she’s with Jesse. My Jesse!
I glance over at Jesse and he smirks. “I met her when I was there for Paul’s bachelor party. I jokingly asked her for a lap dance and even though she may have said no, the night ended differently.” He says as if he’s trying to defend himself to me. I internally self combust.
Throughout dinner Vanessa controls the conversation while finding any and every excuse to touch Jesse or play with his already messy hair. She can see right through me, I can tell. The envy is evident on my thin-lipped grin, but thankfully Jesse is about as clueless as a goldfish. Vanessa though, not so much. Hence why she claims him every chance she can get, going so far as to feed him his french fries. The sight alone is rather unsettling.
“So how long have you two known each other?” Vanessa asks me but Jesse interrupts, answering for me.
“Since the sixth grade. Her last name is Harrison, so we were always paired up together in class. And it kind of just stuck.”
“Do you remember that time Mrs. Polk messed up my name? She called me Claire Hart and all the kids in the class laughed, joking that I was going to marry you one day?” I say, laughing as I think back to that moment now with a smile on my face. Jesse was so embarrassed that even his ears had turned red. Mrs. Polk became my favorite teacher that day.
“How wrong they were.” Jesse laments with a chuckle. “There’s no way I’d be good enough for you.”
Once we get started down the path to memory lane, we don’t stop. We start sharing old stories between us while Vanessa watches the exchange with flared nostrils. Whatever she sees she doesn’t like, I can see it in her narrow baby blue eyes and the slight curve of a frown on her face.
“And remember that time in Mr. Jensen’s class? When he moved our seats for cheating in chemistry?” Jesse asks. He had never been able to master the art of balancing an equation.
I nod my head and start laughing. “Remember when we found a way to pass notes through the Kleenex box? I think he was ready to commit murder when he found out. The vein in his forehead wouldn’t stop throbbing. I’m pretty sure he’s the one teacher who didn’t like me, and we both know he hated you.”
“Oh, without a doubt.” Jesse snorts while slapping the table, making the ice in our drinks clink. “He abhorred us. We were the bane of his existence back then. I’m pretty sure he told my mom that once during conferences. Mary was not happy with me that evening.”
I tilt my head to the side and I sigh. “How is Mary doing? I feel like I haven’t seen her in ages.” I sip my drink through my straw while Vanessa watches me closely with daggers in her eyes. This chick does not like me in the slightest and all I have to say is touché.
“She’s good. She asks about you every time we talk.” Jesse smiles and I swoon sideways on my seat.
Vanessa pipes up, inserting herself into the discussion. “Who’s Mary?”
“My mom.” Jesse replies. “She’s excited to meet you.”
“What have you told her about me?” Vanessa asks.
“Everything. Well, almost everything.” He says while wiggling his eyebrows suggestively. My face blanches as he leans in close to her and kisses her deeply, as if I’m not sitting across from them, watching. I force myself to look away, wanting to crawl out of my own skin just being near them. Wanting to tear my heart right out of its cavity because it’s currently being stomped all over unbeknownst to Jesse.
When he heads for the restroom minutes later Vanessa clears her throat loudly, causing me to jump out of my skin. “So, how long have you been in love with Jesse?” Failing miserably at trying not to give her the satisfaction of a reaction, my eyes bug out of my head, my jaw falls to the table, and I start stammering.
“What, uhh, what do you mean? Me, love Jesse? Uhh, you’ve got to be crazy.”
Vanessa shakes her head while a villainous smile decorates her lips. “Oh honey, it’s written all over your face. Jesse seems to be oblivious, albeit most men usually are, but you're as translucent as plastic wrap.”
I swallow the growing lump in my throat while sweat continues to pool in uncomfortable places. “He’s my best friend. He’s nothing more than that.” I say, my voice coming out all small and weak sounding.
“He’s never mentioned you, you know.” My stomach tightens when she talks. “You think he would’ve mentioned his best friend. Then again it’s hard for him to speak when he’s finding heaven between my legs all the time.”
Heat rises up my neck and straight to my cheeks. I almost want to ask what that’s like but I bite my tongue so hard I draw blood. Just as I’m about to respond she opens her mouth once more. “You two have never fucked, have you?” I shake my head, feeling my ears burn up. “But you’ve wanted to, haven’t you?”
I start playing with the sleeves of my sweater under the table, suddenly finding the fabric fascinating. “Aww that’s so cute. It’s okay if you want to, Claire. As long as you remember that he’s mine. Jesse’s not yours, and he’ll never be yours. Fantasize about him all you want, at the end of the night I’m the one he’s taking home. Not you.”
I find a loose piece of thread along the seam of my sweater and start to tug on it. “I’m well aware.” I say curtly. She must feel threatened by me if she feels the need to remind me I’m not the one sleeping with Jesse because thanks, I know!
“Just wanted to make it clear. Your eyes were giving off lusty vibes during your good old days chat and I can’t have that. I suggest you tell Jesse you’re tired and that you’re heading home early.” I yank harder on the loose string and watch as the seam tightens before I pull the string free.
“Excuse me?” I meet her gaze and her eyes are an icy, crystal blue.
Vanessa sits back and crosses her arms over her ample chest. “You heard me. I want you to leave. I don’t exactly appreciate you lusting after my boyfriend right before my eyes.”
I mirror her movements and reply, “Well, bad news for you because I’m not going anywhere. You’ve known him for one month. I’ve known him for fifteen years. You better get used to having me around.”
She sneers at me just as Jesse returns to the table. Unable to sense the tension between us, he claps his hands together and smiles. “How about some cake?” He says before slipping into the booth, wrapping an arm around her and kissing her again. Unsure of how many more public displays of affection I can stomach, I consider turning in. The only thing stopping me is Vanessa’s prior remark. I’d be giving in to her and I don’t want to give her the gratification of having the upper hand, knowing that she affected me the way that she has.
“Cake sounds great.” I say, plastering a fake smile on my face, making sure to nod in Vanessa’s direction.
“I thought you said you weren’t feeling well?” Vanessa asks me, feigning concern.
“Oh, what’s wrong Claire?” Jesse asks, reaching out and touching my hand for comfort. I hate that I like it and I love how Vanessa responds, her eyes glaring at our clasped hands.
“Nothing’s wrong.” I reassure him but Vanessa continues on with whatever narrative she’s fabricated in her head to get rid of me.
“What about the cramps you mentioned?”
My cheeks flare as I pull on the sleeves of my sweater. “I’ll be okay.” I shrug her off as if nothing’s wrong because nothing is wrong except her being here.
“I don’t know, you look kind of pale.”
Jesse scrutinizes my appearance, with his thick eyebrows knit together in concentration. I flush even more beneath his unwavering stare. “I think she looks good.” Jesse says, shrugging.
There are so many words he could have used to describe me. Fine, okay, alright, but good? Dammit, why’d he have to say good?
“Thanks, Jesse.” I say to him with a small grin. Beside him Vanessa frets. As much fun as it is to poke the beast, being around her is like some special form of hell for me. I stretch in my seat and make a scene of yawning. “I am pretty tired, though. I think I’m going to head home.”
“No, don’t go.” Jesse mumbles, sounding bummed as I motion to the waiter for the check. Beside him Vanessa is beaming. She must be used to getting what she wants.
I cover the bill for everyone and stand up. “I’ll still see you tomorrow, right?” I ask Jesse tentatively. Sunday matinees of old films are a pretty typical tradition for us, although he’s been bailing on me the last few weeks. At least now I know why.
Jesse stands up too, pulling me into a bear hug that warms my entire body. I hide my face in his chest and inhale his familiar pine and cedar scent. Like usual, he kisses the top of my head and pulls away to look down at me while turning my legs into pudding in the process. “I’ll be there, my treat. I promise.”
“I’ll hold you to that.” I say, wishing to stay within his line of vision, only Vanessa’s scowling at me from behind him.
“Have a good night, guys. Nice, err, meeting you, Vanessa.”
“You too!” She says cheerily. “Hope you feel better!”
“Thanks!” I call over my shoulder. What a conniving, sneaky little bitch.