r/surprisecreampies

​

A few nights ago I went out with this older guy (42). We had a great dinner, lots of flirting, and ended up back at his place cuddling on the couch watching something on TV. Things escalated and I was pleasuring him orally when he asked if we could go all the way without a condom. I said okay… but only if he promised to pull out, since I’m not on any birth control.

He suddenly lifted me up like I weighed nothing, carried me fireman-style to his bedroom, and playfully tossed me onto the mattress. Then he climbed on top and started thrusting really intensely. At one point he drove in as deep as possible and just… stayed there, holding me tight. I was so lost in the moment it took me a couple seconds to register what was happening—until I felt him throbbing and releasing everything inside me.

Right after, he pulled back looking guilty and started apologizing, saying he got carried away and totally forgot the plan. But honestly? It felt insanely hot in the heat of the moment. I just grinned, told him not to stop, and let him finish again. Afterward he jumped in the car and went to get me emergency contraception like we originally agreed.

Still gives me butterflies thinking about it 😈

Obviously it was a mistake.

I was visiting my dad this weekend and his neighbor was having a big cookout for his son and nephew's graduation. Dude has a huge backyard with a big deck and pool. Perfect spot for a summer party. He basically invited the whole neighborhood so there were a lot of people there.

Anyway I'm there just enjoying the vibes when the neighbor's son finds me. We will just call him K. I've known K most of my life but I don't live with my dad so I don't really know him know him. Mostly just see each other in passing. K had been in the pool and he was looking extra fine with no shirt on. We end up hanging out and talking most of the night. He's trying to get me to go in the pool with him but I literally didn't pack anything to swim in.

The convo was flirty the whole night. It was pretty obvious where things were heading. He asked if I wanted to go for a walk and we ended up in his car making out. His hands were all over me and I def didn't mind. At some point he said he wished we could find somewhere to be alone and I had a spot. Nobody was home at my place and I had an empty room to myself so we headed there.

We got to my bedroom and he was immediately on top of me. Making out grinding into me and taking off my clothes. When I was down to just my panties he asked if I would suck his dick. He had been hard as a rock for almost half an hour so I know he needed it. I sucked him and it didn't take long for him to cum in my mouth.

We were in bed naked still messing around some and making out. He was getting hard again and said he really wanted to fuck me. I asked him about condoms he said he had some but in his room. I told him I wasn't sure but he SWORE he could pull put if I let him fuck.

So I did and of course he didn't.

He didn't tell me he was about to cum but I knew right away from the look on his face and the change in rhythm that he was done. I said bro did you just cum? All he said was yeah sorry. I was like wtf you said you could pull out? All he kept saying was I know I'm sorry.

The sex was good but obviously that kinda ruined the mood.

Any video recommendations of a stepson who creampies his stepmom accidentally/on-purpose? Then talks about whether his future kid will be his brother/sister or son/daughter?

I’m looking to hear about how you gave/received your first creampie and how the experience was. You can post in the comments or dm me if you wish to remain anonymous.