Me [21] Sister [23] “Truth or dare” came leads to incest with my sister
So, bit of context. My sis and I shared a room most of our lives bc our grandmother lived with us. Essentially, she occupied the bedroom that would have been one of ours (we lived in a three bedroom house). As we got older, my sister and I were use to just changing in front of each other. We would just overt our eyes, but obviously, we’d catch a glimpse of each other. No lie, I often checked out my sis’ butt when she’d bend over to pull up her underwear. She had a nice, hairy pussy. I often jacked off thinking of her tight body and C cup tits! I also became well-endowed, over time, and always wondered if my sister noticed?
So, fast forward and we’re having a sleep over. My best friend and her best friend are there. My buddy and I are actually younger than my sister and her friend. We decide to play “truth or dare” and things get spicy fast. My sister’s friend chooses me, and I chose dare. She keeps giggling uncontrollably, trying to form a complete sentence. Finally, she musters up the ability to say “I heard from your sister that you have a big dick! I wanna see!” My sister, overtaken with shock, slaps her shoulder and yells “JESSICA!?” To which her friend says “Well! Its true! You said it was big and ugly! I wanna see!”.
Jessica was super cute. I mean “Jennifer Love Hewitt” cute. So I figured why not? I stood up and pull out my fully erect dick. “Oh MY GAWD!!?? WHAT THE HELL!!??” Jessica exclaims, bursting into laughter. “Your little brother’s got a big dick!!” “SHUT UP JESSICA!” They continued to giggle like girls.
Now that the nudity threshold was crossed, we didn’t mind crossing that line. Next, my friend was asked to show his dick, which wasn’t as long as mine, but he had a nice thick mushroom head. Of course, the girls giggled about it and commented on its shape and how fat it was. My sister’s friend had pretty big tits, so we eventually dared her to show us her tits. They were a nice shape with big pink nipples and a wide areola area. Well, things got crazy when Jessica (my sister’s friend) dared my sister to touch MY dick. After some back and forth protests, my sister agreed to. It was odd bc she slowly approached it with her hand, like my dick was made of glass. She gently started petting it, like it was a dog. “That’s NOT how you touch a cock!” Her friend said, to which my sister answered something that I never knew: “Well, I’ve never touched one before! It’s my first time!”
As the game progressed, the dares included more nudity and sexual acts. I got to suck Jessica’s nipples, my friend sucked my sister’s, etc. But things reached another level when Jessica double dared me and my friend to show how we masturbate. We stood up, and started showing them. Both of us standing over them, beating our meat, fully turned on by the dare. My sister had a look of wonder, as her eyes were mainly fixed on my dick, as I stroked it to her. I have that image burned in my head. Her sitting on her knees in front of me, her face a few inches away from my dick, as I stroked my dick secretly thinking of fucking her in my mind. I could only imagine what she was thinking, as my older sister, watching her little brother (who now had a man’s dick) stroke it to her. I want to believe that she thought that her little brother’s dick would break her. I want to believe that, at that moment, she was intimidated by the size of my dick and knew that, if sex ever happened between us, her little brother would take the dominant “older sister” role from her.
“Wow! You guys must masturbate a lot! Yall are pretty good! Hehe!” Jessica said, taking my sister and I out of the moment we had. I ceased the opportunity, and said that my buddy and I were owed a “double dare” now. Jessica asked what we wanted, and I took the opportunity to say “I want you both to stroke our dicks, please.” Jessica laughed and didn’t care. She was always boy and sex crazy anyway. My sister looked reserved, but curious. My friend practically shoved his dick in Jessica’s face which, thankfully, left my sister for me (I wanted her anyway). I showed her how to place her hand on my dick, and showed her the motion to stroke me. Jessica had no problem stroking my friend (she obviously had experience). My sister looked over to Jessica, to watch her technique. “It’s kinda heavy!” I recall her telling me, as she continued stroking it. Jessica kept stroking my friend, bc she was in it for the “win”. So my sister, mirroring her, continued. My sister asked when do we stop. Jessica answered “when they ejaculate, of course!”. My buddy and I couldn’t last long, in those days. He came before me, to Jessica’s delight. My sister struggled with the technique, but was eager. Jessica and my buddy came over to watch, which turned me on more, helping me to finally ejaculate. My cum landed mainly on her hands and chest, but a bit landed on her cheek. She was startled by it.
It was a great experience, which opened the door for a few other sexual experiences with my sister.. 😭