"Prove that you're a good girl" [M30sF30sM30s] [Blowjob] [Sharing his girlfriend] [Submissive] [Teasing]
My buddy Matteo was one of those rare guys who didn’t drop off the face of the earth once he got a girlfriend, but he did change once he found Lena. In all the usual ways at first, but eventually I noticed a different shift in his behaviour. He stopped getting offended when the boys made jokes at his expense for falling into yet another relationship so soon. He joined in on the more suggestive jokes about Lena, that slim redheaded beauty. Encouraged them, even. I just took it to mean that he was comfortable and happier than he’d been before. Honestly, I admired his newfound confidence, even if that didn’t stop me joining in on the banter.
One day I was drinking a few beers at Matteo’s place, watching the game with increasingly less idea of what was going on in it. After an hour or so Lena joined us, curling her legs up underneath her and perching on the sofa like a cat.
In my experience she wasn’t a very loud woman, content to watch and listen to conversations rather than have her voice heard when things got rowdy or excited. But that wasn’t to say she was meek or shy. She could devastate any of us with a few words, or turn the conversation to another topic or tone effortlessly. Not shy, but reserved. Observant and intelligent and funny. I could see why Matteo was head over heels for her.
Lena sipped her bottle while Matteo and I churned through the rest of the box with that leisurely pace one finds on a Saturday afternoon with nothing else to do. The game Matteo had invited me over to watch finished, and after some analytical chatter the channel jumped straight into the middle of a women’s basketball game. It wasn’t something we had any familiarity with, but we did in fact have nothing else to do.
When I spotted a tall guard with auburn hair tied back into a short ponytail, I pointed at the screen like a drunken Leonardo di Caprio and exclaimed, “Look, iss you!”
Not my most eloquent work.
The player didn’t really look like Lena, who was slender and angular where this woman was curvaceous and strong. But logic never stopped idiots who’d drank a case of beer before 6pm! And in my defence they were both attractive redheads. We started exclusively following the other ‘Lena’, urging the players to pass the ball to her and cheering for every single thing she did.
Cheering until she committed a particularly flagrant foul on her opposite number. I started gasping like a grandma startled by unexpected blasphemy.
“Oh wooooow. Lena is a dirty player?! She’s been tricking us this whole time!”
“Yeah, it looks like it doesn't it,” Matteo agreed solemnly. “I always knew. She’s kind of a bad boy, actually. That’s what they call her: the bad boy of basketball. Famous for it.”
And instead of rolling her eyes or giving one of her witty retorts, Lena pouted at us both.
“I’m not a bad boy!”
And that was it. No jokes, no explanation, no elaboration. Weirdly that seemed to have struck a nerve, though she didn’t look angry per se. She looked indignant, and that quickly turned to embarrassment as the moment stretched out.
“Okay… I’m sure we didn’t mean-”
“So what are you then?” Matteo cut across me, staring intently at his now blushing girlfriend. Her gaze flickered between us, me on the other sofa and Matteo sitting next to her. She swallowed, but spoke clearly.
“I’m a good girl.”
Her tone was intimate, almost sultry. What made it all very confusing was how both of them turned to look at me after she said it. Matteo smiling and proud, and Lena searching for my reaction. I had no idea what they expected from me, but I definitely perked up. The alcohol suddenly didn't seem so heavy on my thoughts.
I laughed a little nervously and complimented her, assuring her that I didn’t doubt it. But from then on that title became the focus of the conversation. Every mistake from a player onscreen got a comment about her not being a good girl. Every word Lena spoke was judged against her claim. When she offered to go find us some more drinks Matteo told her “You would if you were a good girl.”
The atmosphere in the room was somewhere between erotic and deeply unsettling. At first I didn’t know what to do, or how I was supposed to react to it all. But my role became apparent quite quickly. Matteo would ask my opinion on his statements about the players, and about his girlfriend. He encouraged me to provoke her, and laughed when I did so. He didn’t want me to leave so they could have some afternoon delight, he wanted me to keep going. So did Lena. Her facial expressions were much less scrutable than my buddy’s but her body language told me all I needed to know. She liked this teasing, this public teasing and the role she was now playing. So did Matteo. And so did I. Flirting with your friend’s girl always had a cheeky air of taboo danger to it, even when things were pretty tame. Flirting with her in front of him, while he eggs you on, now that’s a rare vintage. And I was hooked.
After I made a few dramatically sceptical comments about Lena’s stamina, and how lying about it wasn’t something a good girl would do, she finally snapped.
“You don’t know what you’re talking about. You have no idea.”
“Well, prove it.”
That brought things to a screeching halt. Or so I thought. They both froze, and looked at each other, and Lena whispered something to her boyfriend that I couldn’t quite catch. I thought I’d pushed things too far.
“Fine. I will.”
I felt my pants grow tight. It felt too real, too strange, but oh so tempting. Matteo opened his mouth slightly, but he didn't say anything. Their staring threw me off. I didn’t want to ruin whatever freaky shit was happening.
“Um, how about a bet, on the game. Your team against mine. If you lose then you have to prove you are what you say you are.”
Lena pursed her lips and thought for a moment. We all looked at the game. There were another 2 quarters left, with a 17 point difference between the two teams.
“Okay, that’s fun. A little wager on-”
Now Matteo interrupted her. His voice was thick and throaty.
“If you were a good girl you’d do it now.”
Time stood still again. Lena reached over and squeezed his arm.
“Now? …Okay.” She nodded, her face and neck starting to turn crimson. “What should I do?”
“Whatever you want, baby. What we talked about the other night?”
“Oh. Fuck. Yeah, okay. If you’re sure.”
They shared something intense and exciting in their deep eye contact. And then they shared a passionate kiss. And then they turned to me.
Feeling like I was in some incredible dream I stared back at them. My mouth opened, but the words didn’t come out. I didn’t want to say anything to make this dream come to an end. With one hand tugging on her arm Matteo guided Lena off the sofa and onto the floor. She started crawling towards me, slowly.
“She’s gonna suck your cock now.”
I suppose that was his way of getting my consent. Warning me. As well as making all three of us shiver in anticipation.
The distance between us was short, but it felt like she was crawling in slow motion. Lena stared at me hungrily the entire time. Her ass swayed hypnotically.
Her hands were trembling as she slid her hands over my thighs and up to my waist, but that was the only crack in her portrayal of complete subservience. She popped my buttons and unzipped me. I lifted up and she tugged at the denim. Enough for what needed to be done.
I remembered to breathe, and shot a quick glance over at Matteo, in disbelief that he wouldn't be mad, or about to laugh at how carried away I’d gotten over their practical joke. But he only had a lopsided grin for me, and wide eyes fixated on the back of his girlfriend's head.
Lena brushed her palms over the bulge she’d uncovered, working up the nerve to reach inside my boxers. When she did we both moaned at the same time, her even louder than me for some reason. My cock pulsed uncontrollably in her grip. She licked her lips.
When she pulled my cock out of the front of my underwear the first thing she did was slap it against her cheek. I blinked in surprise. She moaned like a pornstar. It wasn’t what I expected from her. I hadn’t exactly fantasised about this scenario in great detail, but I wouldn’t have expected this behaviour from her in a million years. I guess appearances are deceiving.
After smacking herself with my cock she kissed the tip and stroked slowly up and down my length. Peppering me with soft kisses and tentative licks. She looked up at me, the auburn hair framing her delicate features contrasted with the veiny cock in her hands and mouth. My veiny cock, my best friend’s girlfriend’s delicate features. Fuck!
I finally understood what she was silently asking for.
“Do it,” I ordered.
Without hesitation she half swallowed my cock in one smooth movement, not breaking eye contact for a second. I groaned and threw my head backwards. Wet warmth enveloped my dick. I practically saw stars when she swiped her tongue underneath the mushroom head. She was good at this. So good she must have had a hell of a lot of practice.
When I said “Deeper. All of it.” she obeyed without question, again. This pretty girl had a secret weakness. It turns out she would do everything you said, no matter what it was. I was overcome with lust at the revelation. How far could I go? What line would Lena not cross? What would Matteo simply sit and watch me do to his girl?
Lena didn’t complain as she started to gag. She didn’t stop when her eyes started watering. The only break in her composure was her quiet mutters and sloppy gasps when she came back up for air. She bobbed her head up and down quickly before she forced my hard cock into her throat. Each time she did it was with the obvious intention of taking the whole thing inside her. She wasn’t working up to it, and she wasn’t keeping a steady pace. It was all or nothing.
Of course Matteo knew her secret too, and he had a suggestion for me.
“Pull her hair.”
His shorts were down by his ankles and he was jerking off openly. Openly, as if this wasn’t his apartment, or his girlfriend, or his idea! My best buddy had a thick cock. That wasn’t something I thought I’d be learning today. Nor was exactly where his girlfriend’s gag reflex was. But we roll with the punches, I guess. We live and we learn.
Lena’s sun-kissed hair was the key to making her completely feral. Once I took a fistful of it she surrendered all control to me, while still practically throwing herself facefirst into my stomach when I pulled her towards me. The lewd noises of her throat and mouth became louder and sloppier. I bucked my hips up and fucked her pretty face without remorse. The way she had submitted so totally, and just on the whims of us two men, leant me a shamefully misogynistic urgency. She offered herself as a warm throat to be fucked, a toy to be used, a girlfriend to be passed around to anyone. I was going to give her exactly what she’d signed up for.
Alcohol dimmed my sensitivity, but I was still so turned on by this crazy situation. And the velvety embrace of Lena’s mouth and throat was too stimulating to ignore for long. I gripped her hair tightly and made her choke on my cock. She was tight and sloppy and compliant. And I used everything she gave me, which was complete control. My balls tightened and tingled in that familiar way. I didn’t warn her or say anything. I just grunted and unleashed it all into her helpless mouth.
I held on to her hair as my hips thrust towards her, completely uncontrollably. It must have been painful for her, though that wasn’t my intention. I had to fill her up, and there was no consideration for her at all. Maybe I knew that she could take it, maybe I didn’t care. I honestly have no idea. But I do know that she clamped her lips around the base of my cock and rode out the bumpy ride without spilling a drop.
When the last molten pulse left me, I collapsed back into the sofa, exhausted. For the moment my soul had well and truly left me. I had given it all to my friend’s girl.
I think if it had just been the two of us, Lena would have stayed where she was and done whatever else I wanted. Maybe she would have asked for something in return. Maybe she would have begged me to go down on her in return. Maybe she would have sat back patiently and waited for instruction. Maybe she would have climbed up and cuddled me lovingly. Maybe she would have whimpered and laid her head on the floor, sticking her ass up in the air and waited for me to mount her like an animal. I have no idea, truly. The potential for anything was there, wafting around us like smoke. But it wasn’t just the two of us.
“Come here, slut. Now.” Matteo spat, as if he was barking orders to a dog. Lena of course turned away from me and quickly crawled back over to him, but not before she’d flashed her open mouth to me, proving that she'd swallowed it all.
I whispered “Good girl,” to her backside, feeling weak and lightheaded.
When she reached him, Matteo stood up and rammed his prick into her mouth. She propped herself up, palms wrapped around his legs for stability, ready for another facefucking. Maybe it was my ridiculous male ego, maybe it was shame and concern, but I thought that he treated her less harshly than I had. I didn’t know if that was a good thing or not. He was on the edge though, having watched us, and it was only a handful of heartbeats before his face contorted and his knees buckled and he was adding his own sticky load to the back of her throat. He teetered and swayed as he came, and I was worried that he would collapse on top of her. I wasn’t worried that he might choke her or be forcing her to do something she didn’t want, only that he might fall and hurt her by accident. I knew what she was now.
He sat back down heavily, not bothering to tuck his slick member away again. He grinned at me with a slightly manic look on his face before letting his head roll back onto the sofa cushions. His eyes closed and he breathed deeply, recovering and succumbing to the heavy pull of alcohol and post-ejaculation weariness that I too was struggling against.
Once more possibilities raced through my brain and spread out before me in every direction. I looked at Lena with awe and lust, and she looked back at me with… something. She didn’t say anything, or do anything suggestive. But we both knew.
I think that’s what put the willies up me, and made me panic. The fear that both of us knew that a door had been opened that couldn't be shut. We both knew I was attracted to her. We both knew I had permission to do whatever I wanted. I was a little drunk and I knew it. I was scared of what I might do, and how aware I would be of doing it. There wasn’t much to stop me. I wasn’t sure I could look them both in the eye again if I did what Lena and I both wanted me to do. And some gentlemanly decorum in there too; if a man lets his girlfriend suck you off while he watches, it would be rude to fuck her senseless while he was napping. Part of the price is that he gets to watch. And I didn’t want to come across as a boorish guest!
So I zipped myself up, got to my feet, and announced that it was late and that I had to be getting back before it got too dark. Matteo opened an eye to watch me go, but just mumbled blearily in response. I smiled in disbelief at him. Though he’d always been a lightweight, I’d never imagined he would go from cuckold to tired host so suddenly. Lena followed me out of the room to the front door, courteous but visibly disappointed.
Before I opened the door I turned to her, pushed a strand of hair behind her ear, and told her exactly what I was thinking.
“That was incredible. I get it now. I know exactly what a good girl you can be.”
“Not exactly. Not yet you don’t.”
Unable to bear it another second, I grabbed at her, shoving one hand flat against her belly and then pushing downwards, underneath her leggings. Brushing over coarse, prickly hair, I slipped two fingers against her wetness. She gasped and leaned towards me, urging me without words to take what I wanted. It took every last shred of willpower I had to not finger her until she was a mewling, drooling wreck on the doormat. Pulling back, I made her watch me put my fingers to my mouth and taste her sharp-sweet flavour.
Before I could make the promise, she offered it.
“Will you come back next week? I’m sure there’s plenty of other games for us to watch. To watch and to play.”
“Oh, I can come next week too. That sounds perfect.”
And without even mentioning Matteo, we shared a smile of understanding. I stepped out into the night, already planning what we three could get up to next time.