The one that was too big
My wife decided to tag along when I went surf fishing the other day. I jokingly held up a love shrimp and she said, “don’t you dare come at me with that thing!” After a second I responded with, “I bet you’ve never said that to a guy before!” She thought about it for a second and said that she did, once. He was her boyfriend in high school. She was still a virgin and he was rather large, the biggest she’s ever seen in person. She said she blew him all the time but never fucked him. She was scared of what he would have done to her virgin pussy. She has admitted that now she would definitely let him destroy her and probably beg him for more.
I know this guy from school and it makes it even hotter that he’s moved back to our area and is single again.