Dipping our toes into the water
Hey all, I've enjoyed reading all of your stories, so I thought I would share my (32M) and my partner's (30F) journey towards an MFM.
For some background, we were high school sweethearts and have been together for about 15 years. We were each other's first for everything, and she has never been with anyone but me. We're both fairly open to and enjoy being kinky, though she can be a bit shy and nervous about it, especially the first time.
A few months ago, I won a bet with her, and my prize was a kinky night of my choice, and I chose a fake MFM. The night started with us showering together. I ate out her asshole and told her what she had in store for the night. When she couldn't take any more, I got out of the shower and told her I'd be right back and to wait for me. Once out of the shower, I prepared our bedroom: lights off and a suction cup dildo secured and placed on the floor with lube nearby. I returned to the bathroom with a blindfold, which I promptly placed on her. I then led her to the bedroom, laid her on the bed, and ate her out until she was begging for my cock. But, she was getting a different cock first.
I had her stand up and led her to the lubed-up suction cup dildo. I had her get down on her knees, and I positioned the dildo to enter her pussy. She struggled to take it at first, but after a few seconds, she was taking the entire thing. I stood up, sat on a bench in front of her, and guided her mouth to my cock, which she greedily devoured while riding the dildo.
As she was getting her mouth and pussy used, I kept telling her how hot she looked taking two cocks and to ride that big dick harder. I would even occasionally push her up and down on the dildo to make sure she was taking as much as possible. Throughout this, there were countless moments where she was enjoying herself too much and moaning too hard to stroke or suck me, so I would stroke my cock, while telling her to fuck that big cock or cum on it. This went on for a while until her knees got tired, so it was finally my time to fuck her.
I laid her on the bed, slipped my cock easily into her soaking wet pussy, and fucked her as hard as I could until I pulled out and came all over her. Afterwards, she told me how amazing it was and that we needed to do it again soon.
A couple of weeks later, I asked her if she would ever be interested in trying a real cock for an MFM, instead of a dildo, and she said yes. Right now, we're talking through boundaries and scenarios for the first time. Boundaries are going to be no kissing, no one we know or would see again, condoms, and for it to take place while on a trip together. For the scenarios, we have narrowed it down to 2, and both involve her being blindfolded. The first one would involve only me fucking her while she strokes and sucks a stranger. The second scenario would involve me eating her out to get her ready before positioning her on all fours for someone to come in and fuck her from behind, while she sucks and strokes me.
Definitely excited to see where this goes!