I creampied my stepmother
I was nineteen and in college, still living with my dad and my stepmom, Abella, who’d baked every birthday cake since I turned eleven. We were close, and I’d had fantasies about her I didn’t want to admit.
When I reached the door, I stood there on the doormat, listening. That’s because I heard Abella’s voice, which, even through the wall, was easy to recognize since it was so sweet.
“…No, Josh hasn’t touched me since his big promotion. I swear, if I didn’t have my toys, I’d forget what an orgasm felt like.” Laughter, then the chair scraping against tile. “No, I’m not joking. Honestly? I miss getting creampied. Like, the actual mess, you know?”
My fingers froze around the doorknob. I wanted to believe I misheard her, but Abella didn’t really do euphemisms. She never had. My brain short-circuited. Was it a cooking thing? My birthday was next week. Maybe she was talking about baking. It had to be about baking.
Through the window, I saw her in the kitchen, wireless earbuds plugged in, hair loose and glossy. She was leaning over the island, scribbling notes on a pad and plucking grapes from a bowl, phone wedged between her cheek and shoulder. I caught a glimpse of cleavage, Abella’s signature weapon of mass distraction, half-hidden under a loose sweatshirt that read Flour Power.
If anyone had asked me what Abella looked like, I’d have lied and said she was average. Truth, she was objectively hot, and not in the Barbie-doll, high-maintenance sense. More in the way a pinup from the 1950s could outshine every runway model with a single look. She had this long, auburn hair that always looked like she’d just tumbled out of bed, blue eyes that flashed when she got excited, and a body that could convince anyone to eat gluten again. Her ass, enormous, round, a full moon on a good day, broke physics every time she squeezed into yoga pants. I’d spent most of my teenage years trying not to think about her boobs, but they always seemed to lead the way into any room.
I tried not to listen, but my feet kept me rooted to the spot.
Her voice dropped, a little confidential, “He’s barely even home. I mean, what’s the point of a home office if you’re never in it except to check your fantasy football league? I literally bought crotchless panties last month and he didn’t even notice.” A giggle. “No, you can’t borrow them! God, you’re such a perv. I love it. I’ll call you back after Ryan gets in, okay? Love you.”
Opening the door, I pretended I’d just gotten in and was in the process of kicking off my boots.
“Ryan!” she called, rounding the corner. For a second, she looked startled, then her whole face lit up. “Look at you, college man!”
I dropped my backpack on the floor and braced myself for a hug. She wrapped her arms around me and pressed her cheek into my chest, holding on a second longer than necessary. She smelled like vanilla extract and dryer sheets, which made me uncomfortably hard.
“Hi, Abella.”
“You hungry?”
I shrugged. “Always.”
She tugged me into the kitchen and motioned to a chair at the island. “Sit, I’ll fix you something.” She rummaged in the fridge, bent over so far that the hem of her sweats rode up her thighs and flashed a full view of ass. I averted my eyes, which was pointless, since the image was already tattooed on the inside of my eyelids. She straightened, closed the fridge with her hip, and set out the ingredients for a sandwich.
Abella always had this energy, like she wanted to fix the entire world with a plate of food and some well-timed sarcasm. It was impossible not to feel safe around her, even when she was in crisis mode.
Making a sandwich was like second nature for her, and all of a sudden, she slid it in front of me. “Here you go, hon.”
“Thanks.” I took a huge bite, tried not to moan at the taste, and watched her slice an apple for herself. The silence grew. I could tell she was thinking about what to say next, but couldn’t quite land it.
“So,” I said, mouth still half-full, “how’s Dad?”
She snorted. “Same as always. Married to his job. But he loves us in his own way.” She smiled, but her eyes looked tired. “He’s working late tonight, if that’s what you’re fishing for.”
I was, sort of. I was also replaying her phone call in my head, over and over, like a video on loop. Miss getting creampied. I mean, she had to be talking about dessert, right? But if that were true, why did she sound so sad?
I polished off my sandwich in record time.
“Want anything else?” she asked, twirling a strand of auburn hair around her finger.
“I’m good for now.” I suddenly got an idea. I wanted to stop by the bakery and pick up a cream pie for her. Abella had always been so sweet to me, and if she really wanted one, I’d happily get it for her. We chatted a little longer, and I excused myself, saying I was going out for a walk. She told me she’d do some yoga in the meantime, gosh, what a sexy woman.
*****
I hurried to the bakery, and the kid behind the counter gave me a side-eye when I ordered the biggest banana cream pie they had.
When I got home, Abella was still in her yoga pants, a faint sheen of sweat on her forehead.
“Hey,” I said, holding up the white bakery box. “I got you something.”
Her eyes lit up. “Oh? What is it?”
“I stopped by the bakery and picked up a cream pie.”
She laughed softly. “That sounds amazing. You got enough for both of us, right?”
“Of course,” I said. “We can eat it together.”
She got two plates and a can of whipped cream from the fridge. “Lunch of champions,” she said, slicing the pie. We settled down, and I took a bite. The filling was cold, sweet and almost obscene in its richness. “Mmm,” I said, rolling my eyes. “That’s actually insane. It’s so good.”
“It was really sweet of you,” she said, looking me in the eyes.
“You’re welcome,” I told her.
Abella licked her fork and watched me eat. “I like it when you’re happy,” she said. “Makes this place feel less empty.”
I didn’t know what to say to that. I just kept shoveling pie into my mouth, feeling stupidly grateful and a little guilty all at once.
When we were both stuffed, she set down her fork and stretched her arms overhead. The sports top bunched up, revealing a strip of her belly and the curve of her waist, and once she slumped down, her tits crashed down, jiggling till they found equilibrium.
“You’re the sweetest boy,” she said. “Why did you suddenly decide to get me a cream pie?”
“Oh,” I said, blushing a little. “I overheard you on the phone saying Dad never brings one home, so I figured I’d surprise you. After everything you’ve done for me, it felt like the least I could do.”
Her cheeks reddened, and she giggled. “But, uh, ” She hesitated, then smirked. “Do you even know what a creampie is?”
I looked down at the plate and then back at her. “Isn’t it a dessert?”
She laughed so loud she snorted. “God, I love you. Don’t ever change.”
“I’m feeling kinda dumb now … What’s the secret?”
She wiped a crumb from her lip, then leaned in to whisper, “It means finishing inside. Like, during sex. Not dessert.”
My face went nuclear. “Oh.” My voice cracked. “Well, that’s… huh.”
Abella grinned, blue eyes sparkling. “Don’t worry, you didn’t invent being a perv. Boys your age are always curious. And besides, ” she looked me over, head to toe, and for a split second I swore she was seeing through my shorts, “I’d be more worried if you didn’t think about sex at all.”
She squeezed my hand before getting up to rinse the dishes. Her fingers were warm, soft and a little sticky from the pie. I watched her walk away, watched the sway of her hips under those leggings, and I realized two things at once: One, my dad was an idiot for ignoring her. Two, I was completely, hopelessly fucked. And for some reason, that made me smile.
When she came back, she sat next to me again, keeping me company. She set her chin on her hand. “So,” she said, eyes bright and a little devious, “has my sweet boy learned any new vocabulary lately?”
“You mean, uh…”
Her smile widened. “Don’t play dumb. I think it’s adorable. When I was your age, I thought snowballing meant a winter food fight.” She nudged my knee under the table. “So, tell me, what do college girls actually like these days?”
I shrugged. “I dunno. It’s kind of overrated. Or I’m just bad at it.”
She pouted. “Impossible. You’re perfect.”
“Trust me,” I said, “I’m not.”
She leaned in, conspiratorial. “Have you ever… you know, creampied someone?”
I was not prepared for that. “Uh, no. Most girls make you use a condom, even if you’re, like, one hundred percent certain they’re on the pill. And the ones who don’t, well… I kind of, uh, make a mess.”
Abella’s lips parted. “A mess?”
I squirmed in my seat. “Like, too much. It freaks them out. One girl said she felt like she was in a dairy commercial. She wasn’t wrong.”
For a split second, I thought I’d grossed Abella out, but instead her eyes went big and hungry, the way she looked at cake samples at Costco. “That’s so hot,” she said. “I miss when Josh used to, never mind.” She caught herself, cheeks pink. “Sorry, too much information.”
I didn’t know what to do with my hands. “I mean. I wish I could make someone as happy as you seem to be about it.”
She looked up at me, dead serious. “You could.” We didn’t say anything for a long, weirdly electric moment. She played with my hair, tousling it, then drew her hand down to my chest, pressing flat over my heart.
“Josh is always working,” she said, voice barely above a whisper. “He’s a great man, but sometimes I wish he’d remember I’m a woman, too. That I have needs.” She traced a line down my shirt, letting her nails drag just enough to make me breathe funny. “I’m sorry. You shouldn’t have to hear this.”
“I don’t mind,” I said, and I meant it. “You deserve to be happy.”
She squeezed my arm. “You always know what to say.”
I looked at her, really looked at her, and saw the Abella who’d picked me up from soccer games and patched up my scraped knees, but also the Abella who’d confessed, on the phone, to needing so much more than Dad gave her.
For once, I let myself be honest. “If you were my girlfriend, I’d, um. I’d never leave you alone.”
She laughed. “Is that so?”
I nodded, feeling something huge shift inside me. “Yeah. I’d make you breakfast every morning. And pie. And… all the other stuff.”
She bit her lip and closed her eyes. “Ryan, if you keep talking like that, I’m going to do something really irresponsible.”
I waited.
She opened her eyes, blue as the sky outside, and smiled. “Come with me.”
We both rose to our feet, and she took my hand. She led me through the living room, past all the old family photos, and into the guest bedroom, which had a queen-sized bed.
She peeled off her tank top, slow, like she was teasing herself as much as me. No bra, just soft, heavy breasts with dusky nipples, the kind I’d fantasized about for years. Her hands went to her waistband and she slid the yoga pants down, revealing matching blue panties that looked painted onto her hips.
She stood there in the sunlight, gorgeous and a little shy, and for the first time, I realized she was trembling. “Your turn,” she said.
I stripped awkwardly, dropping my T-shirt and basketball shorts to the floor. My cock was already hard, throbbing against my boxers, and when I pulled them down, it sprang free, almost comically rigid.
Abella’s mouth curled into a smile. “God, your cock is nice.” She sounded proud, like she’d raised me herself. “Come here.”
It felt surreal, like a scene straight out of my sexual fantasy, but I was going to enjoy every second of it. I walked to her. She wrapped her arms around my neck and kissed me, her lips as smooth as a youth’s. She quickly deepened the kiss, tongue exploring mine, tasting the last of the pie from my lips. Her breasts pressed against my chest, soft and pillowy, and I couldn’t help myself from reaching down and cupping them, thumbs circling over her nipples. She moaned into my mouth, grinding her hips against me.
She broke the kiss and sank to her knees. Her hands wrapped around my shaft, stroking it slowly, base to tip, then back again. “Can I taste?” she asked.
I nodded, words gone.
She licked the tip, swirling her tongue in little circles, then sucked me into her mouth. She was gentle, her lips sliding down the length before pulling off with a wet pop. She stroked me with one hand while sucking the head, moaning like it was the best thing she’d ever tasted. I nearly came right there, but she squeezed tight and looked up at me, eyes sparkling.
She came off with a pop, and she climbed onto the bed, sprawled out and glorious, then patted the mattress. I crawled up and hovered over her, every muscle on fire with need.
She hooked her fingers in her panties and dragged them down, exposing the pink, glistening sex between her legs. She was already soaked, her inner thighs slick and the scent dizzying.
I stared. “You’re so beautiful.”
She laughed. “You’re sweet. Now … are you gonna give me a creampie or stare at me all day?”
I lined up and pressed in slowly, feeling her stretch around me. She was tight, hot and her walls squeezed me so hard I could barely breathe. I bottomed out, buried to the hilt and Abella gasped.
“God, yes, just like that.” She wrapped her legs around my waist and rolled her hips, taking me deeper, urging me on.
I thrust into her slowly at first, enjoying every inch as her pussy stretched around me. She was snug, hot and slick, her walls gripping my cock like warm velvet that refused to let go. Each slow slide in dragged against her inner ridges, her wetness coating me completely, making every movement smooth and obscene. The scent of her arousal filled the air, sweet, musky, feminine, mixed with the faint vanilla from her skin and the lingering sugar from the pies. It was intoxicating, making my head spin as I buried myself deeper.
Abella moaned beneath me, her legs tightening around my waist and heels digging into my lower back to pull me in harder. “Yes… deeper, Ryan… God, you feel so good raw.” Her pussy clenched around me with every thrust, fluttering and squeezing like she was trying to make me explode already. I could feel her pulse inside, the rhythmic grip that sent jolts of pleasure up my spine. She was dripping, her juices slicking my shaft and dripping down my balls with every pull back. The wet sounds of us fucking were loud in the quiet bedroom. sloppy, obscene and forbidden. I was fucking my stepmom raw. It was thrilling and felt so good.
I picked up speed, hips snapping forward, driving into her with long, deep strokes. She arched her back, breasts bouncing with each impact, nipples hard and pink. Her nails raked down my shoulders, leaving faint red lines. “Harder,” she said. “Fuck me like you mean it.” I obeyed, pounding into her, feeling her pussy open up even more, welcoming every thrust. She was so wet it coated my thighs, the friction perfect. hot, slippery and clinging. Every time I bottomed out, she whimpered, her clit grinding against my pubic bone, her inner walls rippling around me.
She came first, suddenly and hard, her pussy clamping down like a fist, spasming wildly around my cock. She cried out, body shaking, legs trembling as she rode the wave. The sight and feel of her climax triggered mine.
I slammed deep one last time and exploded. My cock pulsed hard, thick spurts of cum flooding her pussy, hot and heavy. I felt every jet shoot out, painting her walls, filling her up until it was too much. She moaned at the warmth, her pussy clenching rhythmically, milking me for every drop. I kept thrusting through it, shallow and slow, pushing my cum deeper inside her and giving her the creampie she so desperately wanted.
When the pulses finally stopped, I stayed buried for a moment, breathing hard against her neck. Then I eased out slowly. As my cock slipped free, a thick stream of white cum immediately leaked from her swollen pink pussy: creamy and glistening, dripping down her slit and pooling on the sheets beneath her ass. She reached down, fingers spreading her lips wide so I could see it all: her pink folds coated and messy, more cum oozing out slowly, running in rivulets down her thighs. She scooped some with two fingers, brought them to her lips, tasting us both.
“God,” she whispered, eyes glassy. “I can still feel you inside me… leaking out. It’s so much.”
I collapsed beside her, heart hammering, watching my cum drip from her well-fucked pussy. She curled against me, one leg draped over mine, still leaking slowly onto the sheets.
“How was that?” I asked her, hoping she’d feel satisfied now.
She kissed my forehead, hair fanned out on the pillow, and giggled. “Best creampie of my life,” she said, voice dreamy.
“I’m glad.”
“Next time I want to feel it twice,” she said with a wink and a kiss. “And I’ll bake you a creampie.”
I laughed out loud, then rolled over and kissed her, tasting sugar and something forbidden and wonderful on her lips.
If this was being bad, I never wanted to be good again.
Thank you for reading! You can find many of my other stories on https://pornreads.com/