u/throwaway6942073736

When I was 18-19 I got back home to the suburbs from college in SF and had too much fun partying and exploring my bisexuality, so my parents decided it was best for me to go to community college.

I never got much attention from girls but a lot of older guys on Craigslist loved me, and I started messaging this older guy and turns out he was DL and discrete (surprise) but he looked in shape and had a nice big cock.

One day I got the courage to meet up with him and went to his place, and he had me park around the block. I knocked on his door and he let me in, and immediately began aggressively kissing me and stripping me down. I didn’t know +50 yo men could be so energetic and ferocious.

He led me to the guest bedroom and pushed me to my knees, where I sucked his cock and listened to him call me a good little slut. It was at this point I was realizing I was catfished, because he was not in shape at all, but his cock was big and the few times I managed to deepthroat him, my nose was buried in his pubes and my eyes and forehead were smothered by his gut.

He fucked my face for a bit before flipping me onto the bed. Then he started fingering me while he had me suck on a glass dildo, before he then started fucking me with that too. He loosened me up before flipping me again missionary, bringing my legs to my shoulders, and fucking me like powerless slut. I knew I was definitely catfished since his face didn’t look anything like his pics, but I was in too deep (or he was?).

He sucked on my tits and mauled em while fucking me for 10-15 min, then he came deep in my ass and bred me. I was rock hard and leaking, but didn’t cum.

Most people would never come back to a hookup where they’d been catfished, but he became my regular hookup. By the second or third visit, I’d gone skinny dipping in his pool while he gave me beer, I sucked and was fucked by him all over his house, and that summer I was his little boytoy.

This was off and on for a few years before I moved away for college again, but I think back fondly to those days when I was 18-20 prancing around naked around a married old cat fishing perv’s house.

True story!