I Thought He Was 100% Straight Until That Afternoon- Part 1
Back in college, I was 21 and in my third year. Our campus had no shortage of insanely attractive guys, but almost all of them were aggressively straight. I used to fantasize about a few of them constantly, especially during hostel nights after smoking or drinking, but I never imagined anything would actually happen.
This story is about one guy from our rival group.
He was 22, dusky, muscular, and carried himself like he owned every room he entered. Even though our gangs hated each other half the time, he used to hang out with us often — smoking, drinking, playing cards, getting into fights. He had this naturally dominant personality that intimidated everyone. On birthdays he would “beat” people as a joke, but honestly I think he enjoyed giving pain a little too much.
And his bulge… impossible not to notice.
Every time he wore joggers, people stared. I tried not to, but I always did. In my head, I had already imagined what it would feel like to touch him.
One evening we were all playing cards in a hostel room when he walked in and said he wanted to join. There wasn’t enough space, so he casually pulled me onto his lap while everyone kept playing like it was nothing.
The second I felt him pressed against me, my brain stopped working.
I still remember how warm his body felt, how confidently he held my waist while talking normally to everyone else. I was trying so hard not to react. My heart was racing so badly that after a few minutes I made some excuse and left the game completely.
A few days later, he came to my room with some friends to smoke in the afternoon. Slowly everyone left for their own rooms to sleep, but since his room was far away, he stayed back.
We ended up sharing my tiny single bed. That part honestly felt normal at first.
But sometime later, while he was half asleep beside me, curiosity took over. I slowly moved my hand toward him and brushed against his bulge.
It was massive.
I got scared he would wake up, so I immediately turned around pretending to sleep. A few seconds later, I suddenly felt his body press against mine from behind.
Then his hand grabbed me.
My entire body froze.
His hand slipped inside my underwear and he squeezed me hard enough to make me gasp. Within seconds I was completely hard. Without saying much, he took my hand and placed it on him.
That’s when I realized he had already pulled his underwear down.
I started stroking him slowly while my heart pounded like crazy. He leaned closer, rough and impatient, trying to guide my face down toward him. I was terrified someone would knock on the door, but at the same time I couldn’t stop.
Everything felt unreal.
He was bigger than I had imagined, and honestly I panicked. Part of me wanted him badly, but another part of me was genuinely scared. He started touching me more aggressively, trying to relax me while I shook from nervousness.
We didn’t have anything except a small bottle of oil in the room, and the whole situation felt rushed, messy, dangerous… which somehow made it even more intense.
But when things started becoming too real, I lost my nerve. I told him I couldn’t do it. He tried to put it inside my hole thrice but it was not going as he was massive n my hole was very tight. Tears on my eyes.
For a few seconds he just stared at me silently. Then he pulled his underwear back on, got up, and walked out without saying a word.
The next day he acted completely normal, like none of it had happened.
But the truth is… even though I was scared, I couldn’t stop thinking about him after that.
And then one night around 3 AM, there was a knock on my hostel door.
I opened it.
It was him.
Drunk. High. And looking straight at me.
Part 2 was where things really changed.